Saving Benjamin is the third episode of the first season.
One day, some of the engines are in the yard talking about their past adventures. When Percy asks Brady if he's ever had any accidents, an engine named Benjamin is brought up. Benjamin is Brady's twin, who he and Olivia think has been scrapped. Kylie then tells them that she saw Benjamin on the Other Railway when Brady, Olivia, and Emily saved her from being scrapped. So, Brady, olivia, Kylie, and Emily journey to the Other Railway to save Benjamin from being scrapped.
- The original title of this episode was Accidents Happen and it was originally going to be very similar to the previous episode with the engines telling stories of their accidents.
- Stock footage from Emily to the Rescue is used.